Some of us are rule followers more than others. I notice that with the students that I teach. There are those who just because I say, ‘do not touch’, will touch and poke and prod just before you yell no!
And then there are others who happily leave the item alone as instructed. Of course, there are also the ‘why’ people who are not willing to follow the rule until they are satisfied they understand the ins and the outs. And then there are some who just did not listen at all, despite my repeating the instructions. Later, when I chastise them or give some other consequence, they are adamant they were never told in the first place. Sigh….
Why am I not surprised then when last weekend, the NSW government had to shut down Bondi beach, after communicating to all Australians about the need for social distancing and a ban on large outdoor gatherings! Did these people not hear, or did they think “this rule does not apply to me”?
My husband booked a weekend for two at the Gold Coast for last weekend. The night before, I was anxious. He was adamant about going and I thought of a dozen scenarios of why it was a bad idea. Getting stuck inside a hotel room was not my idea of a weekend away on the Gold Coast. As a foodie, my idea of a good weekend involves hanging out in restaurants and coffee shops; and that was looking less appealing. The Gold Coast also had known Coronavirus cases and my hometown had none. I did not want to be the one to bring the virus back to our regional town or the school I worked at. If I had to isolate or recuperate, I would lose much needed income. And finally, I reasoned our government had made a recommendation.
I was relieved that after watching the news, my husband agreed it was a good idea to stay home. He postponed our plans and we stayed home. Meanwhile, I watched many of my friends on Facebook go to parties and restaurants. Only few it seemed reduced their contact with others.
I admit that during these unprecedented times, it has been challenging to wade through the hyper anxious scenarios and sometimes even to admit the sober truth. At first, as the rest of the world were falling sick and many vulnerable were dying, I was responding to my students who struggled to understand our school’s request to wash their hands. Some were defiant of protocol, others obsessive in following it. Some were not convinced it was a threat at all and wanted more information. Even my suggestion they source their information from a reliable online source met with mutterings about conspiracy theories. Sound familiar?
As teenagers are inclined to be, many self-focused young people could not see why they needed to worry. After all, teenagers were not the ones dying from this virus. And then, they argued there are no cases here in our town.
Fast forward a week and the situation is different. And the rules have changed. Our state borders have now closed and next week teachers like me will go to school, while most students will stay home on student free days.
At the beginning of this week, I was feeling like the proverbial sacrificial lamb heading into school. Why did I just stay home in isolation all weekend to then head into a classroom of teenagers who like to hug, high five and lean all over the furniture and even me? How much sanitizer and cleaning are enough, I fretted? I too was beginning to question the rules.
Flipping through my Bible Monday night, the words of Romans 13 presented me with a challenge. Paul specifically said to those in Rome; as well as all Christians “Everyone must submit himself to the governing authorities, for there is no authority except that which God has established… Do what is right…” And as a God follower, how clear was that?, I thought.
If our Prime Minister says stay home and do not go out unnecessarily, we should stay home. And if we teachers are to stay teaching then that is the right thing to do for now…no matter how hard that is. Afterall, it is for the good of the whole nation and not just the individual.
Just when I think I have worked through following these rules, there is the matter of this weekend’s local government election. If I do not vote, I am breaking the rules. If I do vote, I must brave yet another gathering of people, risking catching Coronavirus. How fair is that?
What is it about so many Australians that question and do not follow rules? Is it our convict ancestry or is it our rugged individualism? We esteem bushrangers and anti-heroes and yet criticise those in authority, like it is a national sport.
One psychologist, Douglas LaBier PhD says it comes down to how we define what is “fair”. Apparently, people who see themselves as special or are entitled in some way that others are not, are likely to disregard the rules that others will follow, believing the rule is an ‘’unfair” proposition to them. Researchers have found it is very hard to get entitled people to follow instructions. “The entitled people did not follow instructions because they would rather take a loss themselves than agree to something unfair…”
Following this logic, if we do not follow the rules, that makes us entitled or special. If we think something is unfair, then perhaps we are thinking more of ourselves than we ought.
I agree there has been enough abuse of power, including from those in authority. But there are checks and measures in place for that. Surely every time we encounter a policeman, we do not argue with him. What makes us think that in an international pandemic crisis, we are entitled to choose which rules we follow and which we cry “unfair” to? Why do we do our own thing or do the right thing- when we are ready, instead of simply following the instructions of those in authority?
My concern is, just like in the classroom; when too many people do not follow the rules, the consequences will be negative for both rule followers and those that do not. As I often think when I am trying to manage a classroom of teenagers, why can’t people just do as they are told!
And then, I realise I do not immediately think ‘’yes sir’’ or ‘’yes ma’am’’, I can do that! Maybe I am one of those annoying ‘why ’people, who must always know the ins and the outs before I agree to follow the rules.
What about you? If a sign says, “stay on the path”, do you walk on the path,? Or do you question ‘why’ ? Maybe you cry unfair and walk on the grass instead. And if my class is a true sample, some of you will complain when you get in trouble, and say “What sign?”
Photo by Mark Duffel on Unsplash